Mystery Friday Foto #45 Solved: A Motor Parkway Cap from the Wheatley Hills Golf Club
Andrew Carr challenged you to solve where this Motor Parkway hat came from.
Mystery Foto questions:
- Where can this cap be purchased? Provide a rationale.
Andrew Carr found the hat for sale in the pro shop at the Wheatley Hills Golf Club Pro Shop.
- If available, would your purchase this cap?
The hat and its patch of the Wheatley Hills Golf Club historical marker, (which Howard Kroplick has provided the copy for the marker) are available at the club's pro shop along with hoodies and long sleeve shirts. While the club may be private, the Pro Shop is open to the public. So if you've ever wanted some Motor Parkway apparel (hats, shirts and hoodies), head on down to their pro shop! Ask for directions to the Pro Shop at the front desk.
Comments (10)
Congrats to Frank Femenias, Steve Lucas, Art Kleiner, George Philippides, and Brian D McCarthy for identifying the Wheatley Hills Golf Club pro shop. Kudos to Frank, Art and George for their usual great documentation and photos.
Enjoy,
Howard Kroplick & Greg O.
Close-Ups
The actual marker that is recreated on the hat sits on the northern part of the golf course near an intact piece of the original Motor Parkway that was paved over for a golf cart path.
On the southern end of the property is another marker in stone with a bit more in-depth property history. The author is unknown.
Historical Site
"Parkland by the Parkways"
Through Wheatley Hills early years, the club's property was bisected by the Long Island Motor Parkway, which divided the golf course into two nearly equal pieces. The parkway was the vision of William K. Vanderbilt, Jr. and was constructed during the years 1906-1910 [sic]. A millionaire industrialist and sportsman, Vanderbilt initially viewed the parkway as a safe place to conduct the Vanderbilt Cup Automobile Race, an annual contest of international importance that originally had been routed through the streets Nassau County Hempstead and Jericho Turnpike in particular, Ironically, auto racing was outlawed on Long Island in 1917 and the Motor Parkway became a fenced-in toll road connecting Flushing with Lake Ronkonkoma. The bridges and overpasses over existing roads and all rail lines became "the place" for a pleasure drive on a Sunday afternoon. The road ultimately became antiquated, superseded by the Northern and Southern State Parkways, and was closed on Easter Day, 1938. In 1940, Wheatley Hills purchased its part of the parkway's right-o-way and had it landscaped. In the meantime, LILCO's power lines had been installed across the course, paralleling the Motor Parkway's right of way. A portion of the original Motor Parkway still exists between the third green and fourth tee. See plaque marking actual location.
From the history write-up on the Wheatley Hills Golf Club website;
"The Titus farmhouse, a white, two-story, Southern Colonial structure situated to the north of the present clubhouse, served as Wheatley Hills’ first home. An old ship bell, located behind the house and used to signal farm workers at mealtime and the end of the workday, is the only reminder of that period. Now located in the middle of the practice putting green, it once was used to salute the victor in the club’s championship tournament, and is now used to signal the start of shotgun tournaments."
Hats, long-sleeve T's and hoodies of all colors available to Motor Parkway fans.
Howard gets a hoodie
Nov. 11, 2024
The Motor Parkway sat just under the high-tension wires that bisect the course. The northern marker is way off in the distance to the left. The golfway bridge would be approximately in the center of this photo.
Nov. 12, 2024
Yes! There are posts!
Any Motor Parkway enthusiast can take note of the original posts on either side of the former North embankment of the Hillside Avenue Bridge along Williston Ave. close to the main entrance to the club.
Curiously, these posts are either side and not typically how these posts would have been arranged. It is presumed these posts might have been dug up and placed here by the golf course or someone else.
Then & Now: The Motor Parkway in Wheatley Hills Golf Club, East Williston

Comments
Great idea, but the letters are way too small. At least somehow make: “Long Island Motor Parkway” bigger.
Great hat find! The Wheatley Hills Golf Course in E Williston is the only golf course on Motor Parkway’s 45 mile right-of-way that is equally divided on both sides by the parkway. A pedestrian bridge on this golf course was constructed for golfers to gain access to the remaining 9 holes of the 18 hole course. Is this hat available for purchase, or only for club members?
Based on the wording of the emblem, I think you might be able to purchase this cap at the pro shop at the Wheatley Hills Golf Club. That club was formed in 1913 and was split in half by the LIMP. Not being a “hat person”, I probably wouldn’t buy it but I would love to have the emblem as a patch.
I love it.
The cap includes the inscription that refers to the location of the Motor Parkway at the Wheatley Hills Golf Club in East Williston. So I would presume its for sale at the golf’s pro shop. The inscription is the same as on a plaque that sits on the golf course. Photos are from the Centennial book published by the Wheatley Hills Golf Club. The plaque with the inscription shown is from golfadelphia.com.
Additional documentation. I probably would purchase the cap if reasonably priced.
What comes to mind is the old Salisbury Country Club (now Eisenhower Park) where the golf course(s) were originally bisected by the LIRR Central Branch. Once the tracks were pulled up in the 1940s (?) the courses were no longer divided and were combined and the roadbed became a cart path. I would assume that the hats are available for purchase in the current park or at the golf courses. I am not sure that I would purchase one since I don’t golf.
Wheatley HIlls Golf Club?
Rationale: The hat inscription describes the formation of the golf course
Yes, I would buy this hat if available.
Click here to Download this file
Soon as I read the label on the cap, realized the label is a replica of the Historic Sign within the Wheatley Hills Golf Club, in East Williston. LIMP, which was constructed prior to the existence of the Club & Golf Course, ran North & South throughout; creating a golf course on the East & West. There was also a bridge that connected both of the courses. Bridge was originally built for the Titus Farm that existed prior. The LIMP curved West on the North Side. This section was uncovered and kept that way, with the Historical Sign nearby.
I might want to purchase a one of these neat caps from the club!
HOWARD THAT’S THE OLD MOTOR PARKWAY SIGN ON WILLIS AVE. AND THE ENTRANCE TO THE WILLISTON PARK AMERICAN LEGION HALL, 730 WILLIS AVE. BOB VALENTINE SPURRED THIS SIGN AND IS WHERE WE HAVE OUR GREATER NEW YORK REGION AACA MEETINGS ON THE FIRST KNIGHT OF EACH MONTH. IT WAS SPURRED BY THE MOTOR PKWY. ASS. ALSO.
Made in China!